3:06 PM Edit Post
Let's start at the very beginning... a very good place to start .... Every now and then we find lessons in unexpected places. Last Thursday, having the first slow day in several months, I stopped to check a few Facebook messages and noticed this:
Live Chat with Julie Andrews – I LOVE HER! Starting NOW? Fun!
From Mary Poppins the Sound of Music, to her appearances on the The Muppet Show, and The Carol Burnett Show and her films, including Victor/Victoria and even the Princess Diaries... I'd followed her all my life. Since I also track how businesses use social media, participating sounded like it might prove to be a nice little case study to me... so, I clicked to chat.
The chat was obviously getting off to a slow start. I couldn’t see how many had joined, because they didn’t display this in the chat application. Incidentally failure to show participant numbers not only violates commonly accepted practices; it’s a poor way to show the formation of a gathering. There was also Less than one update coming per minute! GRRR.... I almost left, but I really like Julie Andrews.
So I waited… A full 10 minutes and a mere nine (!!) posts later, part of me wanted to scream and the other part was rooting for the event and hoping things would pick up! I jumped in and out of the chat window (easy to do because it was so slow, I didn't miss one update). Leaving the browser window open, I sought some answers elsewhere for my outstanding questions.
What was Julie Andrews' relationship to Target and why were they doing this chat? A visit to the Target Fan Page reminded me that Target is promoting the first annual National Princess Week. The image provided no answers. It only triggered more questions (Right Click to enlarge).
"Okay, " I thought, "It makes sense to promote this event with the beloved, Academy Award Winning Stage and Cinema Actress, Singer ... and more recently, Queen of the Princess Diaries movies. Got it" However, I still didn't quite understand: What was National Princess Week, anyway? Was it something Target made up to sell princess merchandise? You'll note that I wasn't the only one who wondered about this.
There was nothing on the Target.com website about it.... Some people also complained that there was no retail-store tie-in for National Princess Week?
Eager to post a question or two, I went back into the slow grinding chat. Unfortunately, Target opted to use a third-party app that required me to log in with either my Facebook or Twitter handle. I am very conservative with apps on Facebook. I wouldn’t opt-in, because I didn't like the blanket permissions Target's suggested third-party app offered, including posting comments to Facebook on my behalf. Yeah. No thanks!
NEXT, I jumped back into the chat, which continued to grind painfully ahead. I learned nothing surprising. Lots of light questions with simple answers… Her favorite things include tea, roses, poodles, crunchy peanut butter, is proud of her daughters and delighted with her grand children. She has favorite moments, ice cream, etc. She seems enchanting and writes like I would imagine she speaks. Lovely.
However, I wasn’t really learning anything deeper about Julie Andrews. I also couldn’t help but continue to wonder what her stake in this event was.... AND THEN... 23 minutes in to the 45 minute chat, Dame Andrews mentioned her writing with her daughter and posted a link to her website! "Huzzah!" I thought! "Maybe I can find some answers there!" I clicked immediately and here’s what I got:
Criminy! A 500 internal server error message. I refreshed about five times... and got the error each time. I jumped back into Tweet Deck and did an @Target #Targetchat tweet, asking them to tell Julie about the problem. Unfortunately, no one seemed to be moderating the promoted Twitter hashtag, so I have no idea if that comment was shared with Ms. Andrews' team, or not. I got the error for 5-10 minutes.
I was, at this point, rather flabbergasted by the mismanagement of this event. From this unfortunate problem, to the very poor event moderation, to the chat application Target had selected, to the fragmentation of the experience between Twitter and Facebook, to the arduous and slow discussion going on -- it was all just so poorly executed! The strategist in me did a forehead slap.
I jumped back into to the Target Facebook page, where I noticed more problems. First, I noticed someone posting on Target’s wall that the chat application they used by “CoverIt Live” (by Demand Media) wasn’t working.
Okay, that sounds good, right? A decent number of people sharing... commenting? WRONG…. Here’s what I saw in the comments fields…
As if Chat Application vs. Twitter Chat confusion wasn’t enough – people were trying to use the comments fields within Target's Wall Posts as a kind of Chat Window - and Target wasn't monitoring or moderating any of this feedback to redirect people to the right place, either!!
Further, if you read through them yourself, you’ll see that many not only asked great questions, but others complained their questions hadn’t been answered - or were deleted!
A large number of people in this audience didn’t understand that they needed to click to participate -- or use the chat application. People came - but they could not participate in the event! It would have been so easy to engage these people. So much for community management! Fortunately, there was a least one tenacious user:
While the chat slightly improved the last six minutes or so... it never really got going to begin with. Ms. Andrews' answers were polite, positive, light and witty but they had little-to-nothing to do with "National Princess Day” -- so I still didn't know what it was all about. I certainly wasn't alone, as this user graphically points out:
Outside of finding out that her favorite song in Mary Poppins was “Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious” (spelling), I just wasn't sure what we were accomplishing here. Jumping back into my other open tab, I refreshed the link to Julie’s website and the site opened for me. FINALLY - 30 minutes into a 45 minute chat, I began to connect some dots.
While I found her site a bit difficult to navigate, getting into it made Target’s promotion with Julia make a lot more sense to me. That's when the true failure of this promotional effort became crystal clear.
- Julie Andrews actually started National Princess Day in collaboration with Disney and Target.
- She has also co-authored a series of books with her daughter, Emma, and has published her own songs and poetry for children, which are highlighted on the site, along with other recommended books and authors. (The writing did come up during the chat but wasn't eminently clear what books they wrote, what the focus of them were, etc. One line is even a series of princess books.)
- Julie and Emma's books, poetry, songs and lullabies are also for sale in Target Stores - and they have Apps, too. This was not promoted AT ALL during the chat -- I had to do a shopping search on Target to figure this out. They certainly didn't need to make this a sales chat but highlighting this once would have been quite logical and fitting, considering the context.
- The website has all kinds of fun tips and ways to celebrate National Princess Week, creating memories with your kids and teaching important moral lessons. So many cute ideas... also not mentioned in the chat.
- Ms. Andrews and her daughter recently released their new book, "The Very Fairy Princess 3: Here comes the Flower Girl" which was mentioned by a user during the chat event -- but to which no links for browsing or purchasing were shared.
- Julie and Emma also have a Facebook Fan Page, which wasn't promoted or showcased during the event. Unfortunately, neither the new book OR the Facebook page were promoted during the event. And the Facebook page itself failed to promote the chat event with Target.
In the 50 minutes that transpired, there were less than 1.5 comments per MINUTE. There were gaps of 2-3 minutes between posts, and outside of Julie and Target’s comments, there were only 36 unique active participants (active chatters who posted questions). I have no idea how many inactive participants, or “lurkers” there were because this view was blocked by the chat application administrator. However, in parallel to the chat, there seemed to be hundreds posting on the Facebook wall and comments fields – all quite lost and unattended by Target.
This isn’t Julie Andrew's fault, at all. In fact, I’d say she was the spoonful of sugar that made it tolerable for me to hang in there for more than 2 minutes. I find her practically perfect in every way - to the point that I'm a bit intimidated to issue any criticism. less it be misconstrued by Ms. Andrews or her daughter. I don't mean to be ungracious, here.
Unfortunately for Ms. Andrews, due to Target's mishandling of this situation, they were unsuccessful in effectively promoting National Princess Week, her mission to help build self-esteem in young girls and to get children to read, or to make participants aware of products and materials that could make the celebration even better. Further, the audience was unable to make those new, fresh, positive associations to Ms. Andrews, Target or Disney that should have been easy to make! A missed opportunity, really.
I'm not saying this from a high horse... in this confusing era of apps and social tools -- we're all learning at some extent -- especially as these channels converge and complicate communication. However, I expect that a giant like Target would have done the basics much better. I expected they would know better, and I hope they learn from the event instead of shuffling it under a reasonably priced Princess rug.
The fact that I stayed on to write a post about this on a perfectly great beach day is a testament to the weak nature of this promotion. It was such a good case study in "what not to do" for online event management, I may even write a follow-up post that highlights what can be done to make your online event a smashing success - online and offline. But not on a day off...or when I have clients to serve! ;-) Back to the real work.
Labels: bad customer experience, brick and mortar retail, Chat, Community, community management, digital media, multi-channel, target, user experience
- ▼ May (3)
- ► 2010 (26)
- ► 2009 (19)
- ► 2008 (33)
- ► 2006 (35)
- On Trust & Influence
- Don't be Social Media Sharkbait
- The Social Media Engagement Continuum
- 10 Tips for Twitter Unmarketing
- Five Experience Funamentals
- Experience & Branding: The Three Word Rule
- Get Some Experience Healing!
- Discovering Customer Experience Pitfalls
- Not My Job: The CX Enemy
- Shoe Carnival: Watch Out for Carnies!
- Bathroom Usability
advertising air travel bank experience bathrooms Best Practices branding brick and mortar retail charlene li Community Content Copy writing cottonelle customer centricity customer experience customer experience; innovation; customer experience files Customer Experience Leaders customer experience management customer experience pitfalls Customer Relationship Management customer research CX Defining Customer Experience Management economy Ethics experience best practices experience file experience pitfalls good customer experience Group Think Harassment infrastructure Innovation life marketing marketng motherhood old navy personal Plagiarism Plurk privacy reinvention RESOURCES restaurant experience retail experience security Social Media Social Media Expert social networking starbucks stuck target toilet paper trust agents trust continuum Twitter usability best practices user experience UX Web 2.0 Web Strategy word-of-mouth